Can the US Military Afford More Biofuels?

Can the US Military Afford More Biofuels? By Geoffrey Styles Posted on May. 25, 2012 Ed. note: This piece first appeared on Energy Outlook, Geoffrey Styles? blog. Last week the US House of Representatives passed the fiscal 2013 National Defense Authorization Act by a wide, bi-partisan margin. It included two controversial provisions relating to energy that will presumably be debated when the Senate Armed Services Committee takes up the bill this week. Sections 313 and 314 would exempt the Department of Defense from a provision of the Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007 (EISA) barring the government from purchasing alternative fuels with higher emissions than conventional fossil fuels, while prohibiting the purchase of any alternative fuel that costs more than the conventional fuel it would replace, except for testing and certification purposes. If enacted, the bill would require drastic revisions to the current alternative energy strategies of the US military branches. It would be easier to attribute these provisions to partisan maneuvering, if our economic and fiscal circumstances hadn't changed so dramatically subsequent to the passage of EISA in 2007. Although I don't dismiss the influence of election-year politics in such matters, we are now in the third full year of a recovery so weak that many Americans still think we're in a recession, and we face deficits and a ticking debt bomb that forced a reluctant Congress to agree to deep spending cuts starting next January. Nearly $500 billion of those cuts are targeted at military spending. Moreover, our perspective on US energy security has been altered by the emergence of shale gas and so-called "tight oil", and by our recent shift from net importer to net exporter of petroleum products--though certainly not of crude oil. While it remains desirable for the US military to diversify its energy sources, the value of that diversification has arguably fallen. Meanwhile, the biofuels industry, despite tremendous growth and advances, has been unable thus far to compete with petroleum-based fuels without either large subsidies or strict mandates, even with a global price of oil that has remained consistently above $100 per barrel since January 2011. Last year I had a couple of opportunities to question Defense Department officials about their alternative energy strategies, as part of an Army/Air Force energy forum and a subsequent Air Force media briefing at the Pentagon. Although I was impressed by the changing military culture concerning energy and the methodical way they were approaching the introduction of new fuels, I was concerned that at some point the services' procurement of higher-cost renewable fuels would conflict with their other priorities, including the need to replace equipment worn out in Iraq and Afghanistan and to field the next generation of aircraft and naval vessels. What I thought I heard very clearly from the Air Force Deputy Assistant Secretary for energy was that his service was not going into the fuel-production business, and would only buy renewable fuels--other than for certification with their fleet--if they were competitive with conventional fuels. That approach seems very different than the one embodied in the Navy's "Great Green Fleet" initiative. The rationale behind the military's adoption of alternative fuels rests on many complex issues, including the vulnerability of military supply chains and budgets to potential disruptions in oil supplies and price spikes, consistency with the government's imposition of renewable energy mandates on the private sector, and the desirability of reducing the environmental footprint of the military's global activities. There's also the human dimension of personnel put at risk delivering fuel to front-line units, although it's not clear how biofuels would alleviate that risk unless they were produced in forward locations. In any case, however, all these concerns must be reconciled with a realistic response to budget constraints. That looks extremely challenging, and it shouldn't be divorced from deeper questions about the evolving drivers for biofuels or other alternative fuels for the US military. Consider the question of supply disruptions, for example. US oil production looks set to continue increasing and oil imports to keep falling, while we now enjoy a refining surplus that is supporting new product exports. We also have a Strategic Petroleum Reserve that could replace up to half of our net crude oil imports for up to 5 months, or a smaller disruption for much longer. As a result of these factors, it's become more difficult to envision a scenario in which an oil market event affected the military's access to fuels in a manner that the present renewable energy industry could alleviate. And with the cost of most alternatives still above even today's elevated prices for oil and its products, the investment required to develop an alternative fuel industry capable of making a meaningful dent in the military's needs under such a scenario would be very substantial. Should the military make that investment, should someone else, or should it be left to the market? And that doesn't begin to address the issues related to the non-renewable alternative fuels that would be enabled by Section 313, including synthetic fuels derived from natural gas or coal, though these would still be subject to the restriction that they must be price-competitive with conventional fuels. I suspect that the House bill will not be the last word on this subject, though I also imagine that in the new world of "sequestered" budgets and the fiscal challenges that lie ahead, the US military may need to rethink what can be achieved in this area without sacrificing readiness and combat capabilities. It's also important to note that the 2013 Defense Authorization Act's provisions on alternative fuels shouldn't affect the services' efforts to integrate renewable electricity generation, which looks like a real boon for some forward-deployed applications. Back Home ? Back to Top Can the US Military Afford More Biofuels... By Geoffrey Styles? May. 25 2012, 11:03 EST A Cartoon from the Globe and Mail ? May. 24 2012, 11:05 EST ?Wrong Way? Krugman Flies Again, and Aga... By Steve H. Hanke? May. 23 2012, 3:35 EST Will the Feds Kill America?s Future Unde... By Marita Noon? May. 22 2012, 12:03 EST Will LNG Exports Rescue the North Americ... By Pavel Molchanov & Alex Morris? May. 21 2012, 1:03 EST Europe?s Other Power Crisis: Energy By Peter C Glover? May. 18 2012, 3:22 EST Are Chesapeake?s Problems A Red Flag For... By Geoffrey Styles? May. 17 2012, 2:17 EST Brazil Tested by Latin America Energy Po... By Andr?s Cala? May. 15 2012, 2:18 EST Wind Energy: The Wheels are Coming Off t... By Marita Noon? May. 14 2012, 1:13 EST Argentina?s ?Chavez? Risks Shale Potenti... By Peter C Glover? May. 11 2012, 12:54 EST Current and Projected Costs for Biofuels... By Robert Rapier? May. 9 2012, 10:50 EST The Use of Raw Gas as Compressed Natural... By Michael J. Economides? May. 7 2012, 11:44 EST EU Fracking Bans Open Market For U.S. Ga... By Katarzyna Klimasinska? May. 24 2012, 11:48 EST Nuclear Power: No Consensus In Asia Or T... By Graham Land? May. 24 2012, 11:44 EST Consumers Still Favor Gasoline-Fueled Ca... By MSN? May. 24 2012, 11:42 EST Why Jaczko Leaving The NRC Is Good By James Conca? May. 24 2012, 11:40 EST India Needs More Bold Steps On Fuel Pric... By Harsh Joshi? May. 24 2012, 11:33 EST OPEC Has Lost The Power To Lower Oil Pri... By Gregor McDonald? May. 24 2012, 11:22 EST Northern Oil, Gas Hub Visions Need More ... By Bridget Brennan? May. 24 2012, 11:21 EST Natural Gas Prices? Rise Stirs Optimism By Adam Wilmoth? May. 23 2012, 12:27 EST Proposed Wind Farm A Threat To Bald Eagl... By John Murwaski? May. 23 2012, 12:21 EST How To Sell An Electric Car By EV World? May. 23 2012, 12:10 EST Fracking, It?s The Key To Energy Self-Su... By Halah Touryalai? May. 23 2012, 11:30 EST Resource Nationalism: The Usual Suspects... By Jon Mainwaring ? May. 23 2012, 11:21 EST BP To Process Canadian Oil Sands Crude By Erwin Seba? May. 24 2012, 11:28 EST Program In Eagle Ford Aims To Curb Natur... By Vicki Vaughan? May. 24 2012, 11:08 EST Obama Touts Election-Year Energy Plan In... By Fox News? May. 24 2012, 10:42 EST Obama To Push Clean Energy Technologies ... By AJC? May. 23 2012, 10:48 EST Energy Department Seeks To Help USEC By Steven Mufson? May. 23 2012, 10:36 EST CO Court Rules Against Wyoming Gas Pipel... By Steven K. Paulson? May. 22 2012, 11:12 EST Groups Sue Again Over Oil Drilling Off A... By Jim Carlton? May. 18 2012, 10:38 EST Vermont First State To Ban Fracking By CNN? May. 17 2012, 1:03 EST Solar Industry Workers Want Policies Tha... By Zachary Shahan? May. 17 2012, 10:59 EST Canada?s Enbridge to Expand Oil Pipeline... By Edward Welsch? May. 17 2012, 10:50 EST Energy Secretary Steven Chu Touts Arizon... By Ryan Randazzo ? May. 16 2012, 10:40 EST Asian Energy Giants, Shell To Move Ahead... By Washington Post? May. 16 2012, 10:38 EST London Sees Rising Oil, Gas Interest By UPI? May. 24 2012, 11:02 EST Britain Says It Will Add Reactors For En... By Stephen Castle? May. 23 2012, 10:29 EST U.K. Proposes Energy Overhaul To Lure Sp... By Kari Lundgren and Catherine Airlie ? May. 22 2012, 10:57 EST Total Confirms End To North Sea Gas Leak By Fox Business? May. 21 2012, 11:13 EST UAE Plans To Join Gas Opec By Trade Arabia? May. 16 2012, 11:29 EST BP To Seek Oil, Gas In Deep Atlantic Nea... By Linda Hutchinson-Jafar? May. 16 2012, 11:03 EST North Sea Oil Operation To Stop Gas Leak... By Christine Levelle? May. 16 2012, 10:47 EST Canada, Poland Partner To Develop Shale ... By Channel News Asia? May. 15 2012, 10:40 EST Germany To Close All Nuclear Plants By 2... By Hindustan Times? May. 14 2012, 10:53 EST MOL Mulls Joining BP?s Gas Pipeline Proj... By Reuters? May. 14 2012, 10:38 EST Saudi Aramco To Provide Full Crude Suppl... By Sherry Su ? May. 10 2012, 10:59 EST Report Released On UAE?s Nuclear Program... By Gulf News? May. 9 2012, 11:34 EST Putin Defends Decision To Withdraw Gover... By Washington Post? May. 24 2012, 10:48 EST Russian Energy Czar Sechin Takes Helm At... By AP? May. 22 2012, 11:09 EST Shell, Chevron Likely To Win Ukraine Sha... By Pavel Polityuk? May. 10 2012, 11:13 EST Japan Eyes Gas Pipeline From Russia By RT? May. 4 2012, 2:21 EST China Makes New Proposal On Russia Gas D... By Economic Times? Apr. 30 2012, 11:52 EST Eni Begins Gas Flow In Russia Field By Rigzone? Apr. 20 2012, 12:26 EST Greenpeace Protests Arctic Drilling For ... By Gulf Times? Apr. 18 2012, 12:30 EST Russians Follow Chinese Into Canada?s Oi... By Claudia Cattaneo? Apr. 17 2012, 12:19 EST UK Fears Russia?s Nuclear Interest By Tracey Boles? Apr. 16 2012, 12:49 EST Russia: We Would Build Safe UK Nuclear P... By Emily Gosden? Apr. 10 2012, 11:51 EST Russian Government Expects Oil Prices To... By RT ? Apr. 4 2012, 5:15 EST Russia Plans To Build Nuclear Space Engi... By UPI? Mar. 29 2012, 12:04 EST India, Pakistan Sign Pacts For Gas Pipel... By Fox Business News? May. 23 2012, 10:58 EST Turkey?s Imports From Iran Unaffected By... By Press TV? May. 23 2012, 10:42 EST Iran Finds Its First Caspian Sea Oil By Ladane Nasseri and Ayesha Daya ? May. 21 2012, 11:13 EST Bahrain, US Firm Ink Solar Power Station... By Trade Arabia? May. 21 2012, 10:55 EST EU Unwilling To Exempt Korea From Iran O... By Chosunilbo? May. 21 2012, 10:42 EST Iraq?s Fourth Auction Will Boost Oil Hop... By UPI? May. 18 2012, 11:25 EST US Gas Giant Works To Avoid Israel Elect... By AFP? May. 17 2012, 12:28 EST Iran Executed A Man Convicted Of Spying ... By CNN? May. 15 2012, 4:45 EST Iran, Unable To Sell Oil, Stores It On T... By Joby Warrick and Steven Mufson? May. 14 2012, 11:51 EST Aramco Breaks New Ground With Oil Tradin... By Gulf Times? May. 14 2012, 10:56 EST Kuwait Reviews New Oil, Gas Objectives By UPI? May. 14 2012, 10:43 EST New Oil Field Discovered In Caspian Sea By Fars News Agency? May. 11 2012, 2:39 EST China Rules US Clean Energy Support Impr... By Joe McDonald ? May. 24 2012, 10:44 EST China To Boost Private Energy Investment By Pete Sweeney and Langi Chiang? May. 23 2012, 10:39 EST U.S. Orders Tariffs On Chinese Solar Pan... By Don Lee? May. 18 2012, 10:42 EST China?s Nuclear Safety And Development P... By Esther Tanquintic-Misa? May. 17 2012, 12:59 EST China Plans Mega Transmission Power Line By UPI? May. 15 2012, 11:48 EST Qatar Buys ?Major? Stake In Oil Giant Sh... By Alarabiya News? May. 11 2012, 2:15 EST Vice Premier Calls For Energy Co-op With... By China Daily? May. 4 2012, 3:40 EST Coal Industry Restructuring To Continue By Du Juan? May. 3 2012, 3:42 EST Solar Firms Hope For Free Access To Inte... By Nuying Huang, Taipei and Jackie Chang? May. 2 2012, 1:24 EST China Mulls Guarantees For Ships Carryin... By Business Standard? May. 1 2012, 12:36 EST Philippines Accepts Bids For 5 Oil And G... By Canadian Business? Apr. 27 2012, 12:31 EST Oil, Gas At Heart Of South China Sea Dis... By BBC News? Apr. 16 2012, 11:33 EST Australian Companies Get First Shot At G... By David Wroe? May. 22 2012, 11:28 EST South Korea Has No Plans To Halt Iran Cr... By Min-Jeong Lee? May. 22 2012, 10:53 EST Japan Boosts Nigeria Solar Energy Projec... By Victoria Ojeme? May. 17 2012, 12:53 EST Japan Assembly Agrees To Restart Reactor... By Daily Times? May. 15 2012, 10:52 EST Japan To Nationalize Fukushima Utility By Hiroko Tabuchi ? May. 9 2012, 12:40 EST Kenya, Japan State Firms Join To Survey ... By Kelly Gilblom and George Obulutsa? May. 9 2012, 11:24 EST Japan Nuclear Free For The First Time Si... By Today Online? May. 7 2012, 12:43 EST No Deadline For Uranium Sale To India By The Hindu? May. 2 2012, 2:36 EST Power Shortages Expected In Japan By Mari Iwata? May. 2 2012, 11:02 EST India, Japan To Talk On Defence, Nuclear... By Indrani Bagchi? Apr. 27 2012, 12:43 EST Japan, Vietnam Progress With Rare Earth,... By Ryan Huang? Apr. 23 2012, 12:39 EST Japan?s Mitsubishi, Mitsui Ink US Gas De... By Channel News Asia? Apr. 19 2012, 12:39 EST Turkey Warns Oil Companies Off Cyprus Dr... By Oliver Tree? May. 18 2012, 10:58 EST Bulgaria-Greece Gas Link Ready By 2015 By Elizabeth Konstantinova ? May. 14 2012, 11:20 EST EU Firms Among 15 Bidding For Oil, Gas D... By Washington Post? May. 11 2012, 10:48 EST Turkey Starts Oil, Gas Search In North C... By Menelaos Hadjicostis ? Apr. 27 2012, 11:30 EST Israel, Cyprus Deal On Gas, Lebanon Snub... By Eduard Gismatullin? Apr. 20 2012, 12:45 EST Cyprus Oil, Gas Tenders Get ?Positive Re... By Paul Tugwell? Mar. 28 2012, 11:44 EST Israel Opportunity To Bid For Cyprus Gas... By Koby Yeshayahou? Mar. 12 2012, 3:54 EST Cyprus Says China Company Interested In ... By People Daily? Mar. 5 2012, 12:20 EST Greece Invites Bids For State Gas Group By Reuters? Feb. 29 2012, 12:18 EST ? ? ? ? ? ? ? South Africa Looks To Nigeria For Secure... By Bernama News? May. 24 2012, 11:25 EST Sinopec Joins Effort To Build South Afri... By Devon Maylie? May. 21 2012, 10:39 EST New Ethanol Factory Opens In Mozambique By Macauhub? May. 18 2012, 11:38 EST Energy Minister Hopeful On Fracking Repo... By All Africa? May. 18 2012, 11:08 EST Huge Finds Make East Africa Next Big Gas... By Malaysian Insider? May. 17 2012, 12:17 EST Ghana To Export Nuclear Energy To The Su... By Vibe Ghana? May. 16 2012, 11:43 EST Total Begins Bid To Stop Leak On North S... By Christine Lavelle ? May. 15 2012, 11:37 EST France Firm Total Stops Gas Leak In Nige... By AFP? May. 14 2012, 11:10 EST African Energy Makes Coal Discovery In Z... By Energy Business Review? May. 11 2012, 2:42 EST Tullow Disappoints With No Oil In Offsho... By Sarah Kent ? May. 4 2012, 12:48 EST Algeria Aims For Revised Energy Law In 2... By Reuters? May. 3 2012, 10:10 EST Oil Pours From Sudan?s Damaged Pipeline By Ian Timberlake ? Apr. 25 2012, 5:22 EST Iran Is Offered New Plans To Ease Nuclea... By Ali Akbar Dareini? May. 23 2012, 11:08 EST U.N. Nuclear Chief : Deal With Iran Reac... By USA Today? May. 22 2012, 11:23 EST Kurdish Oil Deal Stirs Iraqi Tensions By John M. Broder and Matthew L. Wald? May. 21 2012, 2:51 EST Iran Must Disclose More About Nuclear Pl... By Jerusalem Post? May. 21 2012, 11:07 EST Nuclear Agency Chief To Visit Tehran By George Jahn ? May. 18 2012, 11:41 EST UAE Calls For More To Sign Nuclear Safet... By Awad Mustafa? May. 11 2012, 2:22 EST Poland To Pick Nuclear Technology This Y... By Maciej Onoszko ? May. 10 2012, 11:03 EST Brazil Renews Support For Iran?s N. Righ... By Fars News? May. 7 2012, 12:54 EST South Korea Waiting For Delhi?s Nuclear ... By Economic Times? May. 3 2012, 3:48 EST Iran?s National Grid Receives Electricit... By CRI? May. 1 2012, 5:02 EST Skeptical Iran Open To U.S. Overture On ... By Ramin Mostaghim? Apr. 30 2012, 12:50 EST Russia To Build Two More Nuclear Reactor... By Times of India? Apr. 30 2012, 11:54 EST China Solar Firms Oppose US Tariff Rulin... May. 25 2012, 1:00 EST ? Japan Eyes US Supplies of Natural Gas May. 25 2012, 1:00 EST ? Russia, ExxonMobil Partner to Tap Arctic... May. 25 2012, 1:00 EST ? US Helping India Find Oil Supplies May. 24 2012, 12:17 EST ? Turkmenistan Signs Contracts for Asia Pi... May. 24 2012, 1:00 EST ? US CO2 Emissions Falling May. 24 2012, 1:00 EST ? Syria: Oil Sanctions Take Economic Toll May. 24 2012, 1:00 EST ? Japan CO2 Hopes Resting on Nuclear May. 24 2012, 1:00 EST ? Canadian Gas Potential Gaining Recogniti... May. 24 2012, 1:00 EST ? Oil at $90 First Time in Almost 7mos May. 24 2012, 1:00 EST ? Nebraskans Sue Over Oil Pipeline Law May. 24 2012, 1:00 EST ? ENI Makes Big Oil Discovery in Egypt May. 24 2012, 1:00 EST ?

		China Solar Firms Oppose US Tariff R... May. 25 2012, 4:02 EST [Read More] Japan Eyes US Supplies of Natural Ga... May. 25 2012, 12:11 EST [Read More] Russia, ExxonMobil Partner to Tap Ar... May. 25 2012, 12:08 EST [Read More] US Helping India Find Oil Supplies May. 24 2012, 11:45 EST [Read More] Turkmenistan Signs Contracts for Asi... May. 24 2012, 2:14 EST [Read More] US CO2 Emissions Falling May. 24 2012, 12:56 EST [Read More] Syria: Oil Sanctions Take Economic T... May. 24 2012, 12:52 EST [Read More] Japan CO2 Hopes Resting on Nuclear May. 24 2012, 12:50 EST [Read More] Canadian Gas Potential Gaining Recog... May. 24 2012, 12:45 EST [Read More]

republican debate lewis black kirkwood chris brown and rihanna nightline bloom box brady quinn